May 21st, 2008 | Family survey

A deaf couple in the UK wants to use a deaf embryo to have a baby. Do you think it's right to engineer a child to have a disability?





39 votes, 234 views , 6 comments
 
 
Poll tags:Family, Deaf, Politics, Genetics

 
Add your comment
Update your status line


Comments (6)
Helena94
(Reply)
Missouri, United States

posted May 27th, 2008 at 20:55 CDT

Of course they have the right. Its the moral that I dont agree with, a child should be given all possible advantages. However my cousin is deaf and he gets along wonderfully so Im sure the child even with the disability would be fine. Its not like the parents want the child to have a miserable life so im sure it would be okay.

Dynomoose
(Reply)
Louisiana, United States

posted May 22nd, 2008 at 00:38 CDT

But choosing a disabled embryo over a healthy one?

Drowlord
(Reply)
Texas, United States

posted May 21st, 2008 at 09:16 CDT

The question is euphemistically worded.  They are examining many embryos and genetically screening them for deaf genes... selecting a defective embryo and discarding healthy ones.

Bmccue7
(Reply)
Georgia, United States

posted May 21st, 2008 at 07:38 CDT

I voted the way I did because the embyro was already deaf. Should parents have the right to "engineer a child?" No, not in my opinion. But this child would be born deaf anyway, so being born to deaf parents seems okay to me, from the child's point of view. Deaf parents might be better at teaching and raising a deaf child.

Enjoylife
(Reply)
Fiji

posted May 21st, 2008 at 06:52 CDT

I think that is very selfish of them.  

Scotkitty
(Reply)
Arizona, United States

posted May 21st, 2008 at 05:15 CDT

I don't think it's right to engineer a child period. 

 
Log in using your:

* Username
* Email address
* Password
 
Buddy icon
* Gender
     
* Birth date
Country
City
 (your vote will still count)
Embed Flash Widget
Embed Java Script Widget
Copy & paste the embed code to your site.